Tuesday, June 24, 2025

immigration hypocrisy

 


If President Donald Trump believes in anything, it must be in the imperative to expel every single immigrant living in the country illegally, right?

 

This is one of his core commitments to the MAGA coalition. It’s why he hired ethno-nationalist Stephen Miller as a deputy chief of staff for policy — to reassure his followers that he will stop at nothing to shield them from the murderous filthy criminals lurking just beyond America’s borders. It’s why his border czar, Tom Homan, promised “more worksite enforcement than you’ve ever seen in the history of this nation” to flush unauthorized immigrants from the workforce.

 

The MAGA true believers overlook the fact that Trump’s first and third wives were born in other countries, his mother was born in Scotland, his paternal grandfather was born in Germany, and Melania’s parent were able to enter our country because of a policy known as “chain migration”.

 

Stephen Miller’s grandparents, of course, were Jewish refugees who came here just prior to the stare of WWI. Miller was born on August 23, 1985, in Santa Monica, California, where he was raised, the second of three children in the Jewish family of Michael D. Miller, a real estate investor, and Miriam (née Glosser) His mother's ancestors Louis W. Glosser (originally named Wolf-Lieb Glosser or Glatzer/Glotzer) and his wife Bessie emigrated to the United States from the Russian Empire's Antopol, in what is urrently Belarus, escaping the 1903–06 anti-Jewish pogroms in Belarus and other parts of the Russian Empire. When his great-grandmother arrived in the U.S. in 1906, she spoke only Yiddish, the historical language of the Ashkenazi Jews of Eastern Europe. Miller's uncle recalls that, when Wolf-Lieb Glosser reached Ellis Island on January 7, 1903, with $8 to his name, "though fluent in Polish, Russian and Yiddish, he understood no English.


And speaking of Stephen Miller .... 


Stephen Miller Has Financial Stake in Company Helping ICE With Deportations: Report


 White House Deputy Chief of Staff Stephen Miller's obsession with kicking millions of undocumented immigrants out of the country is a byproduct of his hateful ethnonationalism - but he also stands to make a pretty penny off the administration's deportation agenda.


According to ethics disclosure reports released by the White House, Miller owns between $100,000 and $250,000 worth of stock in Palantir, Peter Thiel's data and intelligence software company that has a several lucrative contracts with Immigrations and Customs Enforcement (ICE) to track data and conduct surveillance on undocumented immigrants. It's a pretty clear conflict of interest from the man behind much of Donald Trump's immigration policy, in an administration that is already rife with corruption.

A Project on Government Oversight (POGO) analysis of disclosures from several administration  figures found that Miller and at least 11 other White House officials and staffers own stock in Palantir, including Gregory Barbaccia, Trump's Chief Information Officer. 

Miller's stake is tucked away in a brokerage account for one of his three young children, all of which are under the age of six. The single degree of separation is still a potential violation of ethics laws. 

Palantir has been a critical player in the Trump administration's efforts to execute the mass deportation of undocumented migrants. The company received a $41 million government contract in 2014, and created custom software for ICE, referred to as Investigative Case Management (ICM). The platform synthesizes massive troves of data on undocumented migrants from various federal and private law enforcement agencies, creating extremely detailed files that are used to craft deportation cases on individuals, and locate them for arrest and detention. 

According to an April report from Wired, ICE awarded Palantir another $30 million contract to create tracking software aimed at providing the agency with "near real-time visibility" into migrants engaging in "self deportation." According to documents obtained by Wired, one of the core functions of the program - dubbed ImmigrationOS - would be to streamline and prioritize "selection and apprehension operations of illegal aliens." The documents noted that one of the difficulties in creating the program was limited access to the biometric data of migrants. 

Last month, reports emerged that Miller had yelled at regional ICE field officers because they weren't rounding up and deporting people fast enough, demanding they achieve a target of 3,000 arrests a day. 

What's becoming clear is that immigration enforcement officials are no longer carefully sifting through data on undocumented migrants in order to round up the criminals that Trump promised would be the primary targets of his crackdown, but casting a drag net over entire communities. 

Several citizens and lawful residents have reportedly been swept up in ICE raids - some held in detention for days or weeks without explanation. One woman, a citizen who was arrested alongside her undocumented husband by immigration authorities, was detained in her ninth month of pregnancy and hospitalized with pains after her release. Another undocumented woman, Iris Dayana Monterroso-Lemus, miscarried in her fifth month of pregnancy after days of pleading with guards at the detention facility she was taken to for medical attention. 

This is what Miller and the Trump administration have desired for some time. According to former Trump Department of Homeland Security appointee Miles Taylor, Miller once proposed using predator drones to "obliterate" ships carrying migrants seeking to land on U.S. soil. It should be no surprise that as Miller moves to fulfill his most vile nativist anti-immigrant fantasies, he's ensured himself a cut of the profits. 


Trump’s stance on immigration is all for show. The swarm of agents from the Department of Homeland Security at a Home Depot in Los Angeles was a performance. Like presidents over at least four decades, Trump understands the business rationale for protecting America’s large and vibrant illegal workforce. He will do nothing to undermine it.

 

There is a little secret that everybody in the immigration enforcement business knows: We have effective tools to prevent unauthorized workers from working. They are not as telegenic as agents in tactical vests running across a Home Depot parking lot to catch a dozen skinny guys hoping to land a plumbing gig. But these tools do have a track record of curbing the incentive that draws people from around the world: available jobs.

That these tools have not been fully deployed underscores the fundamental hypocrisy behind America’s immigration policy. Voters may say they want illegal immigrants to go away. But moms and dads looking for child care, retirees seeking a caretaker, home builders and farmers and landscapers, and everyday shoppers picking up strawberries for their kids’ breakfastall these people rely on unauthorized immigrants’ for their work.

The table below show the employment figures of unauthorized immigrants in various occupations, but you will notice that the majority of them are in the construction trades. If you did a little deeper, you’ll discover that America already has a shortage of affordable housing, and Trump’s policies will only make that worse.

Occupations with the highest share of unauthorized workers

 

Drywall installers

33%

Roofers

32

Painters and paperhangers

28

Other agricultural workers

24

Construction laborers

24

Maids and housekeepers

24

Tile installers

23

Masons

21

Landscaping workers

18

Carpenters

18

Packaging and filling operators

18

Sewing machine operators

18

Laundry and dry-cleaning workers

16

Packers & packagers, hand

15

Food processing workers, all other

14

Dishwashers

13

Manicurists and pedicurists

13

Butchers

13

Chefs and head cooks

12

Taxi drivers

12

Cooks

12

Software developers

12

Tree trimmers and pruners

12

Painting workers

12

Janitors and building cleaners

11

Vehicle and equipment cleaners

11

Housekeeping and janitorial supervisors

10

Total, civilian labor force

 www https://.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2025/06/24/trump-immigration-policy-hypocrisy/

 

Do you remember when Trump said that he was going to drain the swap?

Ironically, the current plans are to construct a massive immigration center in Florida – in a swamp.

Florida is building a detention facility for migrants nicknamed “Alligator Alcatraz,” turning an airfield in the Everglades into the newest — and scariest-sounding — holding center designed to help the Trump administration carry out its immigration crackdown.

The remote facility, composed of large tents, and other planned facilities will cost the state around $450 million a year to run, but Florida can request some reimbursement from the Federal Emergency Management Agency, said Tricia McLaughlin, a spokeswoman for the Department of Homeland Security.

Florida’s attorney general, James Uthmeier, a Trump ally who has pushed to build the detention center in the Everglades, has said the state will not need to invest much in security because the area is surrounded by dangerous wildlife, including alligators and pythons. A spokesperson for the attorney general said work on the new facility started on Monday morning.

 The project is sure to appeal to President Trump, who talked repeatedly during his first term about building a moat along the southern border filled with alligators or snakes. As he pushed for a wall to keep migrants out, he urged officials to build it with spikes, razor wire and black paint to ensure that it would serve as a deterrent, the more terrifying-looking the better.

 The Trump administration is currently holding about 55,000 immigrants, a spike from the end of the Biden administration, when Immigration and Customs Enforcement was holding about 40,000 people.

Trump officials have been pushing Congress to help pay for more funding to expand detention capacity even further. Tom Homan, Mr. Trump’s border czar, has said that the number of detention beds available will dictate the number of deportations that the administration will be able to hit this year.

 https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2025/06/24/florida-desantis-ice-detention-center-everglades/

I’ve written fairly extensive about immigration issues before, but the one that came to mind this morning was the bracero program that started during WWII. Since many of our able-bodied men were now serving in the miliary, produce growers in various states needed someone to pick their crops, so they turned to Mexico for help.

https://tohell-andback.blogspot.com/2021/03/those-darn-mexicans.html

Going back further in time, we used Irish immigrants to build the Erie canal, and there were an awfully lot of foreign-born immigrants who worked on our skyscrapers in the 1930’s.



Trump’s deportation plans are not going as smoothly as he would like. For one thing, he has suffered a number of court cases on immigration.

In addition, individual citizens, as well as corporations, have resisted his efforts. Just last week in Los Angeles, official for the Los Angeles Dodgers did not allow members of ICE to enter the stadium.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8qAnSkkpLe0

We’d all love to see Stephen Miller get deported to a remote island, but that is not likely going to happen. Even if he manages to stay in the country, we’ll eventually revert back to a more rational approach on immigration, even if it takes an election or two to get there.

I’m looking forward to it.

 

 

 

No comments:

Post a Comment